Did you recently quit your job in search of a more exciting career, only to find out that your former employer's non-competition clause is limiting your options? Don't worry, there are many conditions under the law that these types of clauses must adhere to.
The Charter of Rights and Freedoms explicitly protects the right to work. To determine whether the non-compete clause is enforceable, it's important to review your employment contract and seek the guidance of a legal professional specializing in labor law.
To learn more about the requirements of a valid non-competition clause and how to navigate your specific situation, JuriGo can provide valuable insight by putting you into contact with a reputable lawyer that will be able to help you navigate your specific situation.
Pro-tip It's worth noting that legal jargon may refer to non-competition clauses as "covenants not to compete" or "non-competition covenants," which can be used interchangeably.
Exploring Employment Law: Understanding Non-Competition Clauses
Before delving into the intricacies of non-competition clauses, it's crucial to comprehend one of its fundamental principles: the duty of loyalty.
This principle sets the standard of behavior that an employee is expected to exhibit during their employment and even after its termination. It serves as the cornerstone of labor law, defining the employee-employer relationship in numerous significant ways.
In Quebec, the Civil Code explicitly states that employees have a duty to uphold their employer's reputation and avoid publicly disparaging them.
But what does loyalty truly entail? Primarily, it demands that an employee refrain from deliberately damaging their employer's reputation. However, it does not mandate constant praise or adulation; rather, it requires employees to avoid any behavior that could tarnish their employer's standing among other businesses.
In addition, loyalty involves abstaining from any activities that could create a conflict of interest or directly compete with the employer, such as simultaneously working for a competitor.
| Moreover, an employee's duty of loyalty includes the duty to responsibly manage confidential company information . However, it's important to note that not all acquired knowledge qualifies as confidential. To meet this criterion, the information must be specific to the company, challenging to acquire or reconstruct, and kept private. |
|---|
Now that we understand the duty of loyalty, you may wonder, what is the point of a non-competition clause? While the duty of loyalty serves as a baseline standard, it may not be sufficient for some employers operating in competitive, saturated, or contingent environments.
Business secrets can make the difference between a successful business and an insolvent one. Thus, some employers may justify limiting employee mobility through non-competition clauses.
However, be cautious - such clauses must adhere to the criteria of reasonableness stipulated by the law.
Key Requirements for a Valid Non-Competition Clause: What You Need to Know!
Let's discuss the validity of the non-competition clause you signed. Does it meet the necessary criteria or is it unreasonable and therefore null? This clause restricts your fundamental right to do your job, so to be valid, it must comply with the following requirements:
1. Protection of legitimate interests of the employer!
To determine the validity of a non-competition clause, we must consider whether it protects the legitimate interests of the employer.
Legitimate interests refer to the protection of confidential information, business secrets, or client lists that would be compromised in the absence of such a clause. If an employer cannot prove these legitimate interests, the clause is invalid.
Moreover, the clause must be limited in three ways; if any one of these limitations is disproportionate or exaggerated, the entire clause may be struck down.
2. Well-defined and limited geographical region:
Firstly, the geographical region must be well-defined and limited to the minimum territory necessary for the employer's protection. For example, excluding the possibility of an employee working anywhere in Quebec may be considered abusive.
3. Field-specific restriction:
The restriction on competition must be field-specific, meaning that it must be limited to specific functions. An employee cannot be prevented from working in an industry "generally" or "remotely."
4. Time sensitive:
Even if the first two criteria are met and justified, the non-competition clause must provide a specific period of time that limits the employee's right to perform the work in question. An ex-employee cannot be deprived of competing against their former employer indefinitely.
The burden of proof: on who’s shoulders does the duty to demonstrate the reasonability of the clause fall?
It is the employer who must bear the burden of proof in demonstrating the reasonableness of the non-competition clause. They must show that the clause is justified, valid, and necessary. Otherwise, the employee is free to work wherever they choose.
Violating a Non-Competition Clause: Legal Consequences and Your Employer's Options!
If you violate your non-competition clause, your employer may take legal action against you to enforce the clause. Since the non-competition clause is a valid contract between you and your employer, breaching it can lead to the following consequences:
Injunction: An injunction is a legal measure that allows the employer to seek a court order requiring you to comply with the clause. However, the employer must prove that it has suffered significant harm as a result of your breach.
Damages: The employer may also seek damages to compensate for any quantifiable losses resulting from your breach of the non-competition clause. To succeed, the employer must demonstrate that it has suffered a financial loss.
Penalty clause: Some non-competition clauses include a penalty clause that specifies the amount of damages to be paid in case of breach. If such a clause is included and deemed valid, you may be required to pay the amount specified if you violate the clause.
It is important to note that even if your employer alleges that you have breached the clause, it is their responsibility to demonstrate that the clause is reasonable and necessary to protect their legitimate interests.
Non-Competition Clause: Are You Still Bound After Dismissal? Explained
When it comes to dismissal and non-competition clauses, things can get complicated. Are you still required to abide by the clause that restricts your ability to compete with your former employer? This article breaks down the answer into three different scenarios.
If you were unjustly dismissed, you may not be bound by the non-competition clause. However, if you resigned or were dismissed for cause, the clause may still apply. And if you were pushed out by your employer in a constructive dismissal, the clause may not be enforceable.
If you're unsure about your situation, JuriGo can connect you with an employment law attorney who can provide answers and reassurance regardless of your situation.
How will a lawyer break your non-compete clause?
Curious about how an employment lawyer can help you overturn your non-competition clause? Here are some strategies they might use! First, they could challenge the reasonableness of one of the three aspects of the clause - the duration, scope of work, or geographic area covered.
Your lawyer would look for the weakest link in the clause and argue that it is abusive and therefore invalid. Another strategy could be to refute the protection of legitimate interests, as even if the clause meets all three conditions, it will not be valid if the employer has no legitimate interest to protect.
Finally, your lawyer could allege non-compliance with the conditions of formation of the contract. A non-competition clause is a contract subject to the same conditions of validity, and your lawyer may invoke a defect in consent, formation, or legibility of the clause to try to help you.
Contact a JuriGo employment law attorney today to learn more.
Break free from your non-compete clause with JuriGo's employment lawyer partners!
Your right to choose your work and workplace is essential, but a non-compete clause can restrict it. However, it must be reasonable and valid to be enforceable. Many clauses fail to meet this standard, so it's crucial to seek a knowledgeable lawyer's advice.
JuriGo's trusted partners offer expert legal services in labor law and competition matters. By filling out our form, you can get in touch with a skilled employment lawyer who will scrutinize your non-compete clause for free.
Don't let an abusive non-compete clause hinder your career growth. Protect your livelihood and contact us today!