Breach of contracts in the construction industry is not uncommon, and when it occurs, it can lead to significant legal consequences for both parties involved.
Whether you are a contractor facing allegations of a breach or a project owner suffering from a contractual violation, knowing the procedural steps and legal expectations is crucial.
In this article, JuriGo explores the key elements and requirements for pursuing a breach of contract claim in Ontario, as well as the possible consequences and remedies for breaches of construction contracts.
Learn more from JuriGo about the intricacies of contract breaches in general, including in service, sales, and employment contracts!
Overview of Breach of Contract in Ontario
Ontario law recognizes the importance of upholding the terms of a contract and provides legal remedies for breaches. A breach of contract occurs when one party fails to fulfill their obligations as outlined in the agreement .
In the context of construction contracts, breaches can arise from various issues, such as non-payment, non-completion of work, defective workmanship, or failure to meet project specifications.
Key Elements and Requirements for Pursuing a Breach of Contract Claim
To pursue a breach of contract claim in Ontario, certain key elements must be established. These elements may vary depending on the specific facts of the case, but generally include:
| Existence of a valid contract: There must be a valid and enforceable contract between the parties involved. This contract should outline the rights and obligations of each party. Breach of contract: It must be proven that one party has breached the terms of the contract. This can involve demonstrating that the party failed to perform their obligations as specified in the agreement. Notice of breach: The non-breaching party must provide timely notice of the breach to the party in default, usually in the form of a letter of demand . This notice should clearly outline the specific breaches and the desired remedies. Mitigation of damages: The non-breaching party has a duty to mitigate their damages by taking reasonable steps to minimize any losses or costs resulting from the breach. For example, if a contractor breaches the contract, the non-breaching party may seek quotes from other contractors to complete the remaining work. This demonstrates the non-breaching party's good-faith effort to mitigate their damages, which may have an impact on the amount of compensation awarded in the event of a legal dispute. |
|---|
Interpreting the Contract:
When disputes arise over construction contract breaches, Ontario courts will interpret the terms of the contract to determine the parties' rights and obligations.
The courts will consider the language of the contract, industry practices, and the intentions of the parties when construing the contract.
Having a clear and comprehensive contract that covers all aspects of the construction project will help minimize potential disputes.
Consequences of Breaches of Construction Contracts
When breaches of construction contracts occur, they can have significant legal consequences for both owners and contractors. The notable case of D & M Steel Ltd. v. 51 Construction Ltd. in 2018highlights the consequences of such breaches.
The Ontario Superior Court of Justice's decision underscores that both owners and contractors have specific rights and responsibilities, and the breach of these can lead to various legal consequences.
Owner's Breach
If an owner unjustifiably ceases to make required payments, cancels the contract, or makes it impossible for the contractor to complete the work, this is considered a breach of contract. In such scenarios:
- The contractor may abandon the work.
- The contractor can enforce a claim for the value of the work and materials provided up to that point.
- The court may award damages to the contractor, either for breach of contract or on a quantum meruit basis, which refers to the reasonable value of services rendered.
Contractor's Breach
Conversely, if a contractor breaches the contract by delivering defective work, failing to complete the project, or abandoning the work, different consequences ensue:
- If the work is defective or incomplete, the owner can claim damages. However, mere bad work or insignificant non-completion does not generally entitle the owner to terminate the contract. The owner is still obligated to pay for the work done but can seek compensation for the defective or incomplete work.
- If the contractor fundamentally breaches the contract, such as by abandoning the project, the owner may terminate the contract, claim damages, and be released from further payment obligations.
- If the defects in workmanship are not severe enough to constitute a fundamental breach, the contractor should be given an opportunity to remedy these defects. Failure by the owner to allow for such corrections can limit or reduce the damages they can claim.
It is crucial to review the contract provisions and seek legal advice before pursuing any remedies for breach of contract. The specific circumstances and contractual terms can significantly impact the available remedies and the strength of your case.
Contact JuriGo today and we'll connect you with a qualified lawyer in your area to represent you!
Remedies for Breaches
- For Contractors: In case of an owner's breach, the contractor can stop work, claim a lien for the work done (in other words, claiming property or assets that serve as security for the debt), and seek damages. The damages could be based on the actual value of the work performed or on a quantum meruit basis.
- For Owners: When a contractor breaches a contract, the owner's remedies include claiming damages for defective work, non-completion, or abandonment. The damages typically cover the cost of completing or rectifying the work.
Your rights under the law in Ontario
In Ontario, the construction industry is governed by a set of legislation that addresses breaches of construction contracts.
Understanding your rights and obligations as a contractor or client is crucial to navigating potential disputes and ensuring a fair and successful project. Some relevant legislation related to construction contract breaches in Ontario includes:
Construction Act (formerly called Construction Lien Act):
The Construction Act is the primary legislation that governs construction projects in Ontario. It provides important provisions specifically designed to address breaches of construction contracts.
Under this Act, parties to a construction contract have various rights and responsibilities, including the right to enforce the terms of the contract and seek remedies in the event of a breach.
Section 26 of the Act, for example, outlines the right of a contractor to suspend work if payment is not made as agreed. The contractor may also enforce a claim for a lien up to the value of work performed and materials supplied.
| As well, section 6.3 outlines rules on the issuance of invoices. These must be issued by contractors to owners monthly unless the contract states otherwise. Under section 6.4, owners are also required to pay the amount on a proper invoice within 28 days of receipt, unless they dispute the invoice through a notice of non-payment. These provisions ensure that the parties involved can address payment issues promptly, minimizing disruptions to the project. |
|---|
In cases where breaches of a construction contract are severe or ongoing, termination may be an option. Parties may terminate the contract if the other party fails to fulfill its obligations.
It is important to note that termination rights and procedures should be clearly stated in the contract itself. Damages resulting from a breach can be claimed to compensate for any financial losses incurred as a direct result of the breach.
The Construction Act provides mechanisms for resolving payment disputes efficiently. Knowing your termination rights, possible damages, contractual interpretations, and limitation periods will enable you to navigate potential breaches of contract more effectively and protect your interests in construction projects.
Limitation Periods:
It's important to be aware of the limitation periods within which legal action can be taken for breaches of construction contracts. The Limitations Act, 2002 sets out the timeframes within which claims must be initiated in Ontario.
| Generally, the limitation period for contract claims is two years from the date of discovering the breach or when the breach would reasonably have been discovered. |
|---|
A claim is considered 'discovered' on the earliest of two dates:
- When the person with the claim becomes aware of the injury, loss, or damage, understands that it was caused by someone's action or inaction, identifies the responsible person, and realizes that legal action is an appropriate response.
- When a reasonable person in the same situation would have been expected to become aware of these factors.
Consulting legal advice promptly is advisable to ensure compliance with limitation periods, as every case is different and may not necessarily fall under these general provisions.
Why hiring a lawyer is important in construction disputes
Given the complexities and potential consequences of breach of contract disputes in the construction industry, obtaining legal counsel is crucial. The involvement of experienced construction lawyers can help navigate complex legal issues, protect your rights, and strive for a favorable resolution.
Legal counsel can assist in:
- Reviewing and negotiating contracts: Lawyers can help draft clear and comprehensive contracts that address potential issues and minimize the risk of breaches.
- Dispute resolution and mediation: Legal counsel can guide you through alternative dispute resolution methods such as mediation or negotiation, potentially avoiding the costs of going to court.
- Litigation and enforcement: If a resolution cannot be reached through negotiation or mediation, lawyers can represent you in court proceedings and enforce your rights.
- Risk mitigation strategies: Lawyers can help identify potential risks in construction projects and develop strategies to mitigate those risks, ensuring that the contract terms protect your interests.
Find a specialised construction lawyer with JuriGo!
Get legal help today! By filling out the form below, JuriGo will connect you with an experienced construction lawyer in your vicinity to address your concerns.
Our services are completely free and without any obligations!